Domain Names E-CommerceLitigationIP Rights MaintenanceIP as PropertyNews & BulletinsTrademarksIntroductory MaterialsBiotechnologyComputer InventionsUS & Foreign patent Practice
Client AccessHomeAbout UsContact UsOur PeopleSearchQuick Search:

Petty Patent Protection



By John Richards [1]

Introduction


The term "petty patent" is no longer actually used anywhere in the world, its use in Australia having been superseded by the term “innovation patent” in 2001. [2] Recently, however, the term has acquired a secondary meaning, namely any type of protection that is provided for inventions that do not qualify for full patent protection. By far the best known of these are utility models, although other terms such as utility innovations, utility solutions and short term patents are used in some countries. [3]

Until just over a decade ago, an utility model protection was regarded as being something of a curiosity in the intellectual property world. It is true that the Washington revision of the Paris Convention in 1910 had recognized Utility Models as a species of industrial property right, but in his 1975 book "National and International Protection of Patents, Trademarks and Related Rights," Dr. Stephen Ladas listed as having this form of protection only in Brazil, Germany, Italy, Japan, The Philippines, Poland, Portugal, South Korea, Spain and Taiwan. Since then, however, many countries have adopted protection of this type or some other form of "second tier" protection for useful articles or other "low grade" inventions and in the past decade alone over a dozen countries have added legislation providing for protection of this type to their national laws. In Europe, the European Commission has issued a proposed directive on protection of inventions by utility models.


[1] This is an updated version of a paper first published in the Proceedings of the Fordham University School of Law International Intellectual Property Law and Policy Conference 1995 (Juris Publishing and Sweet & Maxwell, 1998). Copyright John Richards 2002.
[2] Petty patents were in fact rarely used in Australia. Their only advantage was that only publications or acts within Australia were considered when assessing novelty. However, the other standards that had to be met were the same as those for ordinary patents and petty patents lasted only for six years. The new innovation patent is intended to be more useful for small enterprises in that the standard of inventiveness required is lower than that required for ordinary patents (what is required is an innovation that makes a “substantial contribution to the art” - there is no need for it to be non-obvious. The term is now eight years.
[3] In addition to patent-type systems, it should be borne in mind that protection for some forms of this type of innovation may also be protectable in other ways. For example, in countries  such as France, design protection can be secured for functional articles and, in certain other countries in Continental Europe, protection against "slavish imitation" is provided by marketing laws.

Next Contents
Contact Us


[Home] [About Ladas & Parry LLP] [Contact Us] [Search]
[Trademarks] [Domain Names & E-Commerce] [Patents & Copyrights]
[Litigation] [IP Rights Maintenance] [IP as Property] [News & Bulletins]

© Copyright 2002 John Richards - Posted July 2002
Please read our disclaimer.