Domain Names E-CommercePatentsIP Rights MaintenanceIP as PropertyNews & BulletinsTrademarks
Client AccessHomeAbout UsContact UsOur PeopleSearchQuick Search:

Litigation / Foreign Patent Litigation

 

Highlights

Civil Law Systems versus Common Law Systems

The world can roughly be divided into those countries that follow common and civil law traditions. Common law traditions are found in most present and former members of the British Commonwealth; subject to caveats that in South Africa and Quebec the basic legal tradition is civil law (Roman-Dutch and French respectively) although intellectual property laws and their application follow the common law pattern. In the rest of the world civil law traditions apply. Outside their home in Western Europe, civil law traditions have been adopted as a result of a colonial legacy, as in Latin America and francophone Africa, as a result of a deliberate act of copying, as in Turkey, Japan, Egypt and Eastern Europe or as a result of a combination of both, as in Taiwan and Korea, where the Japanese imposed their own legal system (copied from the Germans) during their period of colonial domination (Taiwan 1895-1945, Korea 1910-1945). It should, however, be noted that within the civil law family there are difference between whether the predominate influence was that of France (most "latin" countries) or of Germany (most East Asian countries that have adopted a civil law tradition).

Much has been written about the differences in philosophy between common and civil law systems. While in some areas of the law, the differences in philosophy can lead to significant differences in approach to substantive law. Usually these differences in philosophy between the common and civil law system do not have a large significance in the patent field.

 

Foreign Patent Litigation

Patent litigation abroad is different from the United States, both having regard to substantive law, although here the GATT-TRIPS agreement may lead to some harmonization but also in matters of procedure and the cultural milieu in which the legal system operates. This paper summarizes differences in substantive law and procedure that are relevant to the planning of patent litigation abroad.

After a general overview, we will look in some detail at patent litigation in Europe, the major countries of the far east and in Australia, Canada and Mexico. In doing this, we shall consider not only court systems and mechanics of litigation, but also the question of interpretation of patent claims and their scope. We shall also look briefly at the effects of EEC law on the enforceability of patents in EEC member states.


Contact Us


[Home] [About Ladas & Parry LLP] [Contact Us] [Search]
[Trademarks] [Domain Names & E-Commerce] [Patents & Copyrights]
[Litigation] [IP Rights Maintenance] [IP as Property] [News & Bulletins]

© Copyright 2002 Ladas & Parry - Updated on 10/28/2011
Please read our disclaimer.