In 1970, the French designer Yves Saint Laurent (YSL) created and successfully
marketed a long black sleeveless tuxedo-like evening dress, which the YSL
fashion house reintroduced in their 1992 collection. Upon learning that Ralph
Lauren was selling a similar version of the dress in their 1992 collection, YSL
brought suit against Ralph Lauren under the theories of copyright infringement,
design infringement and unfair competition.
In May 1994, the court in Paris decided in favor of YSL and agreed that YSL
owned the 1970 dress design under the law on Designs and Models and also
considered the dress design an original copyrighted creation. The court
awarded YSL damages in the amount of FFr 2 million, half of which consisted of
damages for copyright infringement and half of which was for damages resulting
from unfair competition.
Although legal proceedings under copyright, design and unfair competition laws
against fashion counterfeiting are not new in France, in particular by the
major fashion houses against lower-end counterfeiters, this case is noteworthy
because it pitted two major designers against one another, a relatively rare
occurrence. The damage award is also considered significant for a claim of
this type.

